French Copyright Bill
Delegates to France's Assemblee Nationale voted 286 in favor, 193
against a bill that could drive a wedge between Apple Computer's
iTunes and iPod music players in France.
Apple (nasdaq:
AAPL -
news -
people ) said non to the measure quickly and loudly. The
proposed law, it said, would result in "state-sponsored piracy."
Apple pointed to recent progress in popularizing legal downloads, a
trend which could be dashed if iPod users could freely load their
mini-jukeboxes with interoperable music files. "Free movies for iPods
should not be far behind in what will rapidly become a state-sponsored
culture of piracy," the company warned.
The bill is now set to go before the upper house of the French
parliament for final approval. If it gets put in the statute books, the
law could force Apple, Sony (nyse:
SNE -
news -
people ) and others to share their exclusive copy-protection
technologies with rivals.
The question on everyone's lips is what will Apple do if this
"state-sponsored piracy" does become law. Will it comply, or
withdraw from the French online music market altogether? For now the
Cupertino, Calif-based firm led by
Steve Jobs is refusing to entertain speculation on the issue.
The French government has said it is targeting "absolutely no one" with
the bill, but analysts say Apple is the company with the most to lose.
It seems that a phenomenal penetration of the any market is great for
the bottom line, but it does get the likes of regulators and some
government administrators rather worked up.